Concept

Dominance — where it appears

The relation that makes one stored candidate irrelevant because a later one is at least as good, and the rule that keeps a candidate list short. It is the rule that keeps a candidate list short, and it is what makes a windowed summary's state bounded rather than growing with the window.

Named by 4 essays across 4 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

10⁵10⁶10⁷11010010³10⁴comparisonspeak auxiliary slotsInsertion sortSelection sortBubble sortMerge sortHeapsortQuicksortQuicksortQuicksortShellsortMerge sort with a cutoffn = 8,192, random input5 on the frontier, 5 dominated

The frontier between time and space

The question of which sorting algorithm to use has an honest answer, and it is a shape rather than a name. Comparisons on one axis, peak auxiliary space on the other, and five of the ten algorithms here are on the Pareto frontier while five are dominated — beaten on both counts at once, so that no weighting of the two costs makes them the right choice. Heapsort is one of the five that lose.

space · Space
comparisonsswapsInsertion sort63,071 / 0Selection sort130,816 / 504Bubble sort129,688 / 62,563Merge sort3,964 / 0Heapsort7,653 / 4,170Quicksort5,049 / 2,380n = 512, random inputcounted in the same run

The count somebody chose

Six quantities can now be measured for every sort. Ranking the ten algorithms by each of them and comparing the orders, comparisons and peak space disagree about 91% of all pairs, and memory traffic and modelled misses disagree about 7%. There is no ranking of sorting algorithms; there are six, and choosing between them is a statement about the data rather than about the algorithms.

counting · Count
cash register — every key49,952 bitscash register — HyperLogLog2,560 bitswindow — a stamp per live key8,505 bitswindow — HyperLogLog5,494 bits40,000 arrivals · the popular keys drift, so old keys are gone rather than rare · W = 4,0961,561 distinct in the stream · 169 in the window20× against 1.5×

A register that became a list

HyperLogLog replaces a key per distinct item with a five-bit register, and over a whole stream that is a saving of a hundred times. Ask it about the last four thousand arrivals instead and the same comparison against the same exact structure comes out at five. The estimator did not get worse. The exact answer got cheap.

streaming · Window
counter tablesworst error, ratio to bestquantile summariestuples kept, ratio to bestchain2.18× (323)1.10× (2,807)tree1.00× (148)1.26× (3,211)smallest-first1.24× (183)1.28× (3,278)largest-first2.72× (403)1.00× (2,556)32 shards · hashed · k = 32each column against its own best shape

The shape one structure will not fold

Folding thirty-two shards largest-pair-first keeps 2,556 quantile tuples against a balanced tree's 3,211 — a fifth of the space saved. The same fold on the counter tables beside them leaves 403 counts of error against the tree's 148. A deployment holding both cannot fold once and be right twice.

structures · Merge

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Trade offPareto frontierCacheMeasurementQuicksortRankingState bitsAlgorithm selectionAuxiliary spaceCardinalityCost modelDistinct count

All concepts